Friday, January 26, 2018

A Monument To the Lost Cause

The Confederate Monument in Arlington National Cemetery.

The confederate monument in Arlington National Cemetery was unveiled on Jefferson Davis' birthday in 1914.  In 1900, Congress authorized that a section of Arlington Cemetery be used for the burial of Confederate dead. By 1901 all the confederates buried in the national cemeteries in Alexandria and at the Soldier's Home in Washington were re-buried here. "Among the 482 persons buried there are 46 officers, 351 enlisted men, 58 wives, 15 southern civilians, and 12 unknowns. They are buried in concentric circles around the Confederate Monument, and their graves are marked with headstones that are distinct for their pointed tops." -- Arlington National Cemetery.

This library of Congress photo shows the unveiling in 1914.

"This Chapter in History is Now Closed."

Woodrow Wilson offered these remarks:
 "I assure you that I am profoundly aware of the solemn significance of this thing that has taken place. The Daughters of the Confederacy have presented a memorial of their dead to the government of the United States... My task is this, ladies and gentlemen: This chapter in the history of the United States is now closed, and I can bid you to turn with me with your faces to the future, quickened by the memories of the past, but with nothing to do with the contests of the past, knowing, as we have shed our blood on opposite sides, we now face and admire one another." -- Washington Post,  June 17, 2007.
Many "Lost Cause" monuments were constructed in the early 20th century when the white people of America were able to reconcile after the "the late unpleasantness" at the expense of black Americans who were increasingly discriminated against in what came to be called  "The Jim Crow era." Wilson himself re-segregated the federal bureaucracy in this era, and segregated the Navy for the first time.   

The Iconography of the monument as designed and sculpted by Moses Ezekiel is rich and complex.  The monument is topped by an allegorical statue of a woman representing The South. "Her head is crowned with olive leaves, her left hand extends a laurel wreath toward the south, acknowledging the sacrifice of her fallen sons. Her right hand holds a pruning hook resting on a plow stock. These symbols bring to life the biblical passage inscribed at her feet: 'And they shall beat their swords into plow shares and their spears into pruning hooks.'" -- ANC.

On the pedestal on the south face of the monument is the seal of the Confederacy and a dedication.

The 1863 Confederate statute that established the seal says:
Resolved, by the Congress of the Confederate States of America, That the seal of the Confederate States shall consist of a device representing an equestrian portrait of Washington, (after the statue which surmounts his monument in the capitol square at Richmond), surrounded with a wreath composed of the principal agricultural products of the Confederacy, (cotton, tobacco, sugar cane, corn, wheat and rice), and having around its margin the words: “The Confederate States of America, twenty-second February, eighteen hundred and sixty-two,” with the following motto: “Deo vindice.”
As Thomas Pickett put it "And thus we have a succinct and accurate description of that which symbolized the once formidable but ephemeral Confederacy."

The dedication says:

Our Dead Heroes
The United Daughters
of the Confederacy
Victrix Causa Diis Pacuit
Sed Victa Catoni

The Latin adapted from Lucan's poem Pharsalia meanings something like "The winning cause pleased the gods but the losing cause pleased Cato", indicating that the winning cause was fortunate but the losing cause was more just.

A frieze below the statue depicts a mix of allegory and genre scenes. On the south face we find an image of Minerva the goddess of War and Wisdom helping to support a swooning woman who represents the fallen South leaning on the Constitution.

The Fallen South Leaning on the Constitution

Soldiers, Miners and Sailors march off to join the cause beneath "the Spirits of Avar" blowing their trumpets.

A young woman ties a sash around the waist of her lover who is leaving for the war.

A minister and his wife bless their son who is leaving home to go to war.

A blacksmith's wife upbraids him and urges him to join the cause.

A Young soldier kisses his infant child held up to him by an enslaved African American servant,  while an older child cries on her skirts.

Confederate soldiers march under the eyes of angels. Marching with them is an African American body servant. (See Andy Hall's discussion of the "Black Confederate" at Arlington.)

On the back (northern) side of the pedestal is an inscription signed by Confederate chaplain Randolph Harrison McKim.

Not for fame or reward
Not for place or for rank
Not lured by ambition
Or goaded by necessity
But in simple
Obedience to duty
As they understood it
These men suffered all
Sacrificed all
Dared all  -  and died

McKim had been Chaplin of the 2nd Virginia Cavalry and was later pastor the Church of the Epiphany in Washington, DC.

Randolph Harrison McKim

Lieut. Randolph H. McKim, 1862

The Rev. Randolph H. McKim, D.D. 1904

The Monument is signed by sculptor Moses  Ezekiel.

M Ezekiel Sculptor

M. Ezekiel, Sculptor

Moses Ezekiel's dying request was to be buried near his sculpture in Arlington Cemetery. He was not actually a Confederate soldier but  he was a graduate of the Virginia Military Institute and had fought at New Market. In 1921 his body was returned to the U.S. and buried here. His funeral was held in the Memorial Amphitheater.

Moses J. Ezekiel
Sergeant of Company C
Battalion of Cadets
Virginia Military Institute

On the band between the Statue of Peace and the frieze are 14 state seals. There were 13 states of the Confederacy, if you count both Kentucky and Missouri. The fourteenth is the seal of Maryland. Though not a Confederate state Maryland supplied men and support for the Confederate cause.


The U.S. Army intends to remove a Confederate memorial from Arlington National Cemetery next week as part of its ongoing work to rid Defense Department property of divisive rebel imagery, defying dozens of congressional Republicans who have vociferously protested the move.



  1. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

  2. This monstrosity should be torn down!

    1. Democrats started the civil war. Better to get rid of hatefilled Democrats.

  3. I truly hope this monument will be allowed to remain at Arlington Cemetery for all it truly represents this "Lost Cause"
    as is stated here...It was not for Slavery and the cause was due to a Northern Tax on Southern Products. Research this and know the Truth..and understand that My Southern Heritage has been discriminated..demoralized..and slandered viciously for150 years since the war to the extent of today's removal of monuments ...history or other symbols of the cause to the extent of causing a hatred to Southerners Heritage in our country..and only 2 groups in the history of America has this been promoted and supported by and allowed to be justifiable
    since the Constitution was made a law are true Southerners
    and Indians.This is and has been for 150+years allowed to be and should never ever been allowed ..and would not be allowed to do to any other groups ever. This is a disgrace and i am ashamed that our government allowed orchestrated and Indied supported and has publicly been shown as doing so...and has taken it to the level it is today...and has been witnessed as true fact of their promoting and allowing this act of political slander and involvement to destroy our right as citizens theGod Given Right and the Constitutional Rights given to all groups of people that right to honor their heritage regardless..and exempt only 2 groups from that right .May God be as a witness that this is and will always continue until our government reverses and restores our dignity of our heritage and compensates us for the damage it caused thru withholding the truth of the lost cause. God Bless Us All as Americans and Our Government for the Lies that continue to destroy the Dignity Of All as One Nation Under God for the Betrayal they have and continue to do to our United States of America...Amen!@

  4. In the interest of reconciliation, I will agree with "anonymous" that this monument should remain. It marks the moment when the US turned away from the path of full equality for all and accepted second-class citizenship for African-Americans as the outcome of the Civil War. An event that will haunt us well into the future.